Summary: Something happened that caused John to give up Sam and Dean. John managed to kill the demon, and though he meant to return and get his kids back, he died with the demon, leaving Sam and Dean in separate foster homes that they both ran away from. They meet several years later, not knowing their past connection.
Original recommendation by Keitorin.
This story is rated M. Readers must be 18 or older. This story also contains yaoi/slash.